It’s finally time for us to move on, LiveJournal.

You and I had a good run together. Twenty years, in fact, since our relationship started back in 2002. 1,350 journal entries, between my general and cycling blogs.

But boy have you changed. In 2007 you were bought out by a Russian company, but I stayed loyal to you when most of my friends left for your alter-ego: Dreamwidth.

Since then you have: fired your American staff, broke a promise by relocating your servers to Russia, adopted partisan Russian censorship policies in your terms of service, prohibited other blogging platforms from crossposting to LJ, and made it difficult for users to export their existing blog entries to other systems.

I don’t know at what point your behavior crossed the line, but it obviously has. At this point, my earlier choice to distinguish between LJ’s policies and those of the Russian state seems naïve.

With that distinction removed, it becomes much harder to pay for a service hosted in an authoritarian country that is engaged in a clandestine hacking war upon the United States, and an unjustifiable invasion of neighboring Ukraine.

Between LiveJournal’s own policies and those of the Russian state, things have finally gone too far. So after 20 years with you, I’ve finally joined Dreamwidth, who will host my general and cycling blogs going forward.

Yup. Twenty years, beginning on February 16 2002 with this post, where I shortsightedly stated, “You shouldn't expect to see very much in the way of public postings.” That was the first of 1,350 entries (so far).

I found it telling that I observed that 20th anniversary by posting a status update on my Facebook, rather than LJ. Previously, I’d written about my feelings on the fifth anniversary and the tenth anniversary of my blog.

Henceforth all new postings will appear on Dreamwidth, where I’ve imported all my old LJ posts and settings. As you might expect, a few things didn’t come across perfectly, but I’ll try and iron those out over time. If you notice anything missing, broken, or ugly, I’d appreciate if you let me know.

As a reader – however infrequently that might be – you can expect my blogs to continue as they always have, save for the obvious change of domain name. Hopefully the only change you’ll notice will be a return to posting more often.

Blogposts per Year (stacked) chart

From Robert Anton Wilson’s “Nature’s God”:

A diary is the only place you can discuss philosophy without immediately being placed under observation by the police.

Blogrot

May. 5th, 2002 09:02 am

I find it surprising that a nation that reads so much can write so poorly. Some reasonably good advice for all you blograts can be found in this ALA article.

Okay, this rant has been coming on for a while now, and now its time has come. This isn't meant to knock anyone in particular. In fact, it appears the whole world could be painted with this particular brush; each of the examples I cite below came from a different user's journal...

So I've been reading a couple people's journals that they keep on LiveJournal, and I must admit that's it's pissing me off. Here's why.

As I see it, there are two types of journals: one chronologically documents significant events in time, and the other is a place for exploring your private beliefs and feelings and reactions, and basically "working through" stuff, or at least recording the stuff that you worked through. That's why, when you look at my Web site, you get a listing of important or significant things that happened to me; and when you look at my LiveJournal, you tend to find fairly detailed opinions and thoughts.

Now, when I read other people's journals, I get neither of those. I get things like "I bought some cheese today", or "I hope I don't have to go to the DMV", or "I took an online test to see what Buffy the Vampire Slayer character I would be". Other people's journals are full of inane crap that is absolutely without any meaning or significance whatsoever. There's no unique viewpoints, there's no depth of character, there's no thought at all! And these entries aren't even valuable as historic documentation of significant events, because they rarely even get personal enough to deal with anything more than the mundane trivia of everyday life.

Let me attack this from another angle. When I share part of my journal, or when I note a special event on my Web page, it's because I want the reader to be able to connect with me and understand or empathize with me at a meaningful level. I want to share the joys of my life with others, as well as the unique insights that I've gained along the way. That's what I offer the reader, even if that reader is just myself ten years in the future. That's also what I, as a reader, expect from others' journals: I want to be able to connect with someone at a level that's beyond the inane surface that usually rules face-to-face interactions. When I have read someone's journal, I want to feel like I know that person better than I did before. Your journal is you being you, perhaps more candidly than you ever would in person; it's a sharing of who you are and what you value.

Or so I would expect, but that's not being borne out in my observations of real life. Sure, LiveJournal is a social phenomenon, and maybe I'm just expecting too much from a glorified public bulletin board. But if I were to judge solely by their LiveJournals, I would think that people in general are even more inane and shallow than I ever thought possible. If "I went to the bank and then bought a new highlighter" and "I forgot the sausage for dinner and had to go back" and "I'm making meatballs now" is the extent of what really matters and is important to people, so much so that they spend time recording it for posterity, I think that goes a long way toward explaining why I prefer isolation to society, and why sometimes I'm at such a loss to find anyone I can interact with on a the meaningful level I value. I really do hate to be so negative, when I've been trying hard to turn that around recently. And thank god there are the infrequent exceptions whose depth of character is a blessing I cherish; otherwise I'd surely either go mad from alienation or be labelled so by the majority for being so "different"!

"Got no life? Try LiveJournal -- no life required!"

Okay, so I finally succumbed and joined the inane self-indulgence that is LJ.

Why?

Well, primarily because an online journal is easier to write in than one stored only on my home machine. There are more opportunities for me to store pertinent thoughts, wherever they occur. And why should I create my own journaling system, when LJ has done a reliable job at it already?

But you shouldn't expect to see very much in the way of public postings here. Although I'm an exceedingly open person, I have no intention of using LJ as a public forum. If there are things I specifically want to share with people, they'll probably appear as friends-only posts; but my default will be to keep everything private.

If you're desperate to know what's going on in my life, you can always go to the online "newsletter" that I've been keeping since the beginning of 1998. You can find it at http://users.rcn.com/ornoth/.

Frequent topics