I just thought I’d take a sec to recall the last couple days before I left for Korea, since they were a bit notable.

Monday I went and saw the Toasters at the Middle East. The level to which they—and ska—have sunk was underscored by the fact that they were playing the upstairs, rather than the big room downstairs. And the show overall reflected it. The only person left from the Toasters at their best is Bucket, and… well, they’re not as tight by half, and the songwriting’s gone downhill. It’s great to see them carrying on, but it was also pretty melancholy to such a great band brought low.

The other thing I wanted to note was that Tuesday was a Gordon & MacPhail scotch whisky tasting at Federal Wine. Here’s the lineup:

  • Benromach 6
  • Bladnoch 13
  • MacPhail’s 15
  • Benromach Portwood 22
  • Millburn 27
  • Glenrothes 30
  • Athol Brose liqueur

The young Benromach was surprisingly good, with a nice smokey flavor when I would have expected something really raw. The Bladnoch was another pretty characterless lowland. The MacPhail’s is an independent bottling of… I think it was Glenfarclas, and wasn’t bad. If I recall correctly (must take tasting notes at these events, even if it *is* in cramped quarters), the Glenrothes was quite a different experience. But the liqueur was just a bad case of spewage waiting to happen. That’s not one I’ll ever forget. Yaggis!

So there’s this liquor store in Gummint Center: Federal Wine & Spirits. I’ve never been there, but I read on BeerAdvocate that they had a decent selection of scotch whiskies. And last week they were having a scotch tasting.

Now, it was put on by the Speyside distillery, and I really had never heard of Speyside (the brand, not the region, which is famous for its distilleries). Basically, I went into the event expecting to be given some comparatively inane spirits. In fact, I was going there more to see if I could pick up some Bruichladdich for our next scotch night than to try the Speyside.

I’d been warned the place was small. It was about the size of my kitchen, in fact, but lined to the rafters with liquor. I also knew that the tasting would take place in the cellar, so I climbed down the staircase that was barely wide enough for my hips.

The cellar was, indeed, a cellar. Like, cement walls and floor, and piled to the beams with boxes of liquor. It warn’t no fancy wine cellar!

Port Ellen 21

My first big surprise was that somehow they’d stacked about 250 people in this cellar little more than twenty feet square. It was kinda reminiscent of the Rat when Powerman 5000 played there, except better lit. Somewhere beyond my sight I could hear a soft-spoken voice blathering in Scots, and I saw a couple guys in suits traversing the mosh pit, serving. I snagged a glass and got a dram of something (it turned out to be a sneak-preview of Speyside’s 12 year old) that presumably wasn’t on the tasting sheet. Tasting sheet?

I had just gotten a tasting sheet when I heard the magical words “Port Ellen”. Port Ellen was one of the most beloved distilleries when it was shut down twenty two years ago, and the few remaining bottles are very, very highly prized. And it looked like I was going to get some… for free!

See, in addition to the Speyside, that company owns something called “Scott’s Selection”. Before he started the Speyside distillery, its founder was a warehouser, and he collected barrels (and barrels) of fine scotch. This is a common scenario, leading to what are called “independent bottlers”, which are often a source for hard to find malts, cask strength bottlings, and other such specialized products.

One look at the tasting sheet and I almost shat meself. Aside from the mundane Speyside, they were serving six whiskies, all at cask strength, two of which were from distilleries which closed decades ago, with an average maturity of 26 years, and which command an average price of $230 per bottle! This was insanely good stuff.

Here’s the official list, just so that you can drool a bit:

Longmorn 35 Y.O. 1968 61%
Glenlivet 33 Y.O. 1968 52%
Littlemill 20 Y.O. 1984 62%
Macallan 31 Y.O. 1973 44%
Highland Park 19 Y.O. 1985 54%
Port Ellen 21 Y.O. 1982 52%

Needless to say, I was absolutely blown away. If my friends’ whisky night was like Christmas, this was like… I dunno, I don’t even have the words.

And, yes, I did go home with a bottle of that Port Ellen, not so much for myself but for some friends who know how it should be valued, as well as the Bruichladdich. My Visa took a torpedo, but letting that Port Ellen come all the way to Boston and elude me is something I know I would have regretted for the rest of my daze (sic).

Frequent topics